Sunday, January 23, 2011

Of Mice and Men-Chapter five response


In the novella, Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, Curley’s wife is depicted as many things and they are mostly bad, but did she deserve what happened to her?  Curley’s wife is often seen as the antagonist of the story because she is responsible for “killing” George and Lennie’s dream.  But, is she really the cause of this?  She was just looking for someone to reach out and talk to, because in the time of the book women were not treated as equals of men, and this is depicted throughout the book by John Steinbeck because he doesn’t even give her a name all anyone calls her is “Curley’s wife.”  She is treated like and outsider all she is “supposed to do” is stay at home and cook and clean and do everything for the man of house, but she never gets to be herself or do anything especially in the depression era.  This prompt can tie into the last prompt because maybe the reason she is jailbait and flirts with all the guys is because she is lonely something she has in common with Lennie, Crooks, and Candy.  She talks to Lennie and realizes that he is just a little kid in a big big body and she says this in this quote, “‘you’re nuts,’ she said. ‘But you’re a kinda nice fella.  Jus’ like a big baby.’”  And she lets him feel her hair and this leads to that and so on.  But, maybe she just needed someone to be there for her to pour her feelings into and understand her and that was exactly what Lennie did for her just like he did for Crooks.  But she never deserved what she got.  No one deserves that, especially just because she was a so called “tramp.”  So all in all Curley’s wife can be seen as a tramp a flirt or even jailbait, but she is still a loving caring human being and she just wants the “American Dream” and she knows she cant do it without being with a man.  So she flirts around and wears fancy clothes so she can try and get that dream.  But, she is mistreated and misunderstood and she tries to reach out and she is killed, now why would anyone deserve that?

5 comments:

  1. I Like the way you picked your quotes but I agree that she didn't deserve her death but I still think she is the one that dug her own grave. She still may dress like a tramp and maybe act like one but she still digs her own grave.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I disagree with you where you said that she was the one responsible with killing Lennie and George's dream. I think Lennie accidentally killed their dream, because during the scene where Lennie kills her, she did not do anything to deserve it. She let him feel her hair. I like the way your quotes tie in with your thesis

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like how pointed out that she is often seen as the antagonist when really she may not be. Your quotes helped support your thesis that she may be more innocent than people give her credit for. I think you succeeded in proving your point.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that she didn't deserve to die. I disagree with the fact that she killed their dream because it wasn't her that did anything, it was Lennie. Besides that i like the way you concluded the essay and your point was proven

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with you that she most certainly did not deserve to die. Your quote selection was done well too. They really supported your thesis which was written perfectly as well. You captured the 5 parts and everything flowed. Good job bud.

    ReplyDelete